Recipe: Pan Simmered Capretto (Baby Goat) with Tomatoes, Onion, Parsley, and Herbs



(photo: pan simmered baby goat or capretto with onion, tomato, garlic, and red wine)

Feasting on baby goat is a staple of our Italian American Easter and Christmas dinners.  My father’s mother, Nonna Rosa Scordo, made a wonderful pan simmered capretto recipe and it includes braising a whole baby goat (which is processed at home or by the local butcher).  

Here’s the recipe:


  • 1 large mason jar of whole crushed tomatoes with liquid 
  • 1-2 large onions, coarsely chopped
  • 2 cups of homemade red wine (or any dry, and rustic, varietal from Italy or France)
  • 8-10 large cloves of garlic
  • Dried oregano
  • Freshly ground black pepper and kosher salt
  • 1-2 cups of freshly chopped Parsley 

The cooking process is straightforward and includes first searing the pieces of meat in olive oil  over high heat.  Note the capretto pieces should be seasoned well prior to searing.    Remove the meat after nicely browning it on all sides.  Add the onions and garlic and fresh olive oil to the pan and saute the for 5-10 minutes over medium heat.   Next, add the tomatoes, wine, oregano, and 1/2 of the chopped parsley to the pan and mix quickly.  Place the capretto pieces in the pan and simmer on low for 2.5 – 3 hours.  You’re looking to braise the meat and get the consistency of shredded pork or nicely cooked beef short rubs; that is to say, the meat should fall off the bone and be fork tender!   

Note that Nonna Rosa also marinated her capretto pieces for 8-10 hours prior to cooking; this step is optional in my view.    Also, if you’d like to cook the dish in the oven you can simply place your all metal pan and lid in the oven and cook at 350 degrees F for 2.5-3 hours.

A Little Bit about Baby Goat or Capretto
When it comes to selecting the appropriate Capretto for a holiday meal or Sunday lunch, my grandmother was notorious for prosecuting the local butcher as to the source and freshness of the Capretto.  Moreover, she had the butcher swear on his dead relatives that the Capretto was, in fact, baby goat and not adult goat which is tougher and gamier in flavor (you see once goats begin grazing on grass, they develop a mutton-like flavor which, unless you’re accustomed to such flavor, can be a little odd).  The idea of prosecuting the local butcher stems from the fact that Nonna was accustomed to baby goat that was raised on her own land; fighting with the butcher in the US somehow dulled the pain of having to buy ingredients (including meat) from someone else (an unheard of concept in rural Calabria).   
On the nutritional side, goat is very low in fat and cholesterol (in fact, goat is 40-60 percent lower in saturated far than chicken and beef, respectively).   Capretto flavor components are rich and complex (sort of like, beef, short rib) and I encourage folks to experiment and try preparing a dish of roasted or pan simmered Capretto!


  1. Italian Rituals: The Sunday Visit

    (photo: nonno and nonna’s New Jersey basement where I first experienced the “Sunday Visit”)One of the nicest Italian rituals I continue to observe to this day is the “Sunday visit”  The idea of the Sunday visit is centered on…

  2. Review: Gargiulo Sorrentolio Venus Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil 2009

    (photo: great, bright, yellow color in the Gargiulo oil)There are a few Italian food products that take a bit of getting used to; I would include items like amari or digestivi, authentic espresso, meats such as rabbit and goat,…

  3. The Italian Deli and Creminelli’s Artisan Meats

    The Working Life and the Italian DeliI’ve held many odd jobs as a young lad including garbage man, janitor, landscaper, handy man assistant, electrician’s assistant, travel agent, HTML editor, maintenance man at a woman’s clothing shop, and, my person…

  4. Recipe: Roasted Butterflied Chicken on the Barbeque

    (photo: a freshly butterflied whole chicken with lemon zest, Kosher salt, and ground black pepper) One of the earliest food memories I have is of Nonna Vincenzina slaughtering a young chicken on Via Nazionale in Calabria.  Nonna simply walked into…

  5. Chicken Cacciatore (Pollo alla Cacciatora)

     (photo: chicken cacciatore / chicken hunter’s stew or pollo alla cacciatora with herbs, onions, and white wine)There are hundreds of variations on the popular Italian dish cacciatore or alla cacciatora (or in the style of the hunter, in Ital…

  6. I just picked up half a baby goat (head and all!) for the Easter holiday. We marinate it in white wine, garlic, olive oil, fresh parsley and rosemary for a few hours then we grill it on a barbecue until medium to fully cooked. I LOVE this pan recipe and will save some of the cuts for this one in the week or so.

    Grazie e Buona Pasqua 🙂

    • Never tried grilled baby goat, but I’d love to try the method one day! We also marinate our goat, even when roasting / pan simmering (I think it necessary given the characteristics of the meat). The head is a great part!

  7. Vince what cut of goat do you ask the butcher for?  We go to a butcher on Arthur Avenue so I’m certain there’s no problem getting it.



    • Hi Bernardine! We always order a whole baby goat and have the shop butcher it into pieces. I haven’t seen too many local shops sell baby goat pre-butchered.


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.